With

Series

The Cross and Creation - a fresh look at Penal Substitution

Published

1.27.2023

The Cross and Creation - Part 7 - Which model fits best for what happened at Calvary?

In this latest edition in the Cross and Creation series, Tony and Andrew explore some of the metaphors for what happened at Calvary. None of them really fit the Penal Substitution metaphor. They range over several metaphors like reconciliation, and redemption, but focus in on adoption and dominion; Calvary was the great battle for dominion of the cosmos, and we are adopted into that kingship won at Calvary. The episode begins with a recap of our journey thus far.

To assist with the talk Andrew has provided a short set of Powerpoint slides on the subject. Please see the "Download Documents" link below.

Download documents

More from the series

Is penal substitution an answer to the wrong question?

The Cross and Creation - Part 6 - Metaphors

The Cross and Creation - Part 5 - Anselm

The Cross and Creation - Part 4 - The Sacrifice of Isaac

The Cross and Creation - Part 3 - Dominion

The Cross and Creation - Part 2 - What are the challenges in Creation?

The Cross and Creation - Part 1 - What are the questions?

Interview with Matt Clarke - Disrupting Mercy

Andrew Baartz

Latest podcasts

How order not sin frames Genesis pt 2

Sin is obviously animportant word, and central to the Christian doctrine. But it is also a loadedword, and one that works like a sinkhole to suck in streams of meaning – someof which may not be helpful.

How order not sin frames Genesis

In essence, John says that it is ‘order’ (and what he calls the ‘order spectrum’) that frames the thinking in Genesis – not ‘sin’. He implies (what I would say more boldly perhaps) that the ‘sin’ framework is a modern anachronistic reading – whereby we are reading our modern paradigms backwards into the text.

Tony Golsby-Smith

Five ways to reframe the gospel

In this final talk, I summarise five profound ways that the Exodus narrative reframes and stretches the traditional gospel of Penal Substitution.

Tony Golsby-Smith

Drama and the humble God

Here is the third talk in our journey through Exodus as an analogy of redemption. In this talk we explore Exodus through the lens of drama. Of course, the whole Bible is in essence a drama in that it is a narrative or story grounded in events rather than abstract ideas.

See all podcasts